Nothing was as she thought. All the decisions she’d made were based on something that might not be true.

“I worked all summer so I could hire a detective,” Bobby said, raising his head slightly and looking at her. “I wanted to find you and tell you the truth.”

He looked young and scared—two things she could relate to.

“Are you going to talk to them?” he asked. “They still miss you, Elissa. They don’t talk about you much, but your pictures are everywhere and at Christmas, they always fill your stocking.”

A couple of tears escaped and ran down her cheeks. Walker’s strong hand gave her something to hold on to and she squeezed his fingers as hard as she could.

She remembered her stocking. She’d made one for Zoe that looked just like it.

“My mom’s the one who taught me to sew,” she told Walker. “She could make anything.”

“She would be impressed with what you’re doing now,” he told her.

Maybe, she thought, considering the possibility for the first time. How odd. Nearly as strange as thinking she might not be alone in the world anymore. That she might have people she could lean on.

Just then the waitress appeared with their drinks. She set them down without saying anything and hurried away. No doubt the display of emotion made her uncomfortable. Elissa knew she wouldn’t want to be serving this table.

“What are you going to do?” Bobby asked tentatively. “Do you want me to tell them?”

“No,” she said slowly as she wiped away the tears. “I need time to think about all this. I guess I’ll go by and see them.” Should she do that? Should she call first? Dropping in on them didn’t seem right, but she wasn’t sure she could figure out what to say on the phone.

“Can you tell me when?” Bobby asked. “I want to be there to tell them what happened. I’m ready for them to know what I did.”

There was something in the way he said the words that made her think he meant it. Part of her crowed that it was about time, while another part of her appreciated his willingness to grow up and accept the consequences.

“Sure,” she said. “I have your cell number. I’ll give you a heads-up when I’m ready to make an appearance.”

He nodded, then swallowed. “I know you hate me, Elissa. I deserve that. But I hope, eventually, we can, you know, be close again.”

“I don’t hate you,” she said reluctantly. “I’m not happy about what you did, but I can almost understand it.”

Tears filled his eyes again. “Thanks. I, ah, wondered. Did you keep the kid?”

For the first time since walking into the diner, she smiled. “Yes, I did. Her name is Zoe. She’s five. Which I guess means you’re an uncle.”

Bobby brightened at the thought. “Yeah? Cool. Can I meet her sometime?”

“Sure.”

Suddenly she felt as if she’d run a marathon. Her body ached and she couldn’t seem to catch her breath. She dug ten dollars out of her jeans’ front pocket and tossed it on the table.

“We have to go,” she told her brother as she released Walker’s hand and slid out of the booth. “I’ll be in touch.”

Bobby scrambled to his feet where he topped her by at least six inches. “You promise?”

She nodded.

He leaned forward and wrapped his arms around her. She resisted the embrace for three heartbeats, then hugged him back.

Walker was silent on the way to the car.

“You have to tell me what you’re thinking,” Elissa said. “I can’t read your mind.”

“I want to beat the crap out of him.”

“I’d probably have to stop you, but I appreciate the support.”

He held open the passenger door. “You really think you could stop me?”

She stared into his dark eyes. “Physically, no. But I could try reason. Or a food bribe.”

“Pie might work.”

She smiled. “That can’t have been pleasant. Thanks for coming with me.”

“You’re welcome. How are you doing?”

“I don’t know. Everything is different. When I woke up this morning, I understood everything about my past and how it made me the person I am. Now that’s all changed. I’m angry and I can’t figure out why or at whom. Everything is different.”

“You’re still who you were before.”

“Maybe. But for how long? I’ve gotten used to being alone. Now I have a family again.”

“Is that a bad thing? You like being with people. Mrs. Ford, your friends from work.”

“That’s different. I chose them.”

As he walked around to his side of the SUV, she wondered if she’d chosen Walker or if he’d chosen her, and if, in the end, it would matter.

CHAPTER ELEVEN

WALKER MOVED THROUGH the large space. He wasn’t sure where he was—maybe a ballroom in a hotel. There were so many lights everywhere—lights and noise and the sound of women’s laughter.

He circled the crowd, aware of being out of place. He was thirsty and while there was a glass in his hand, he couldn’t lift it to his mouth and drink. Was it too heavy? No, it was his arm. He couldn’t move his arm.

The lights faded, then blurred. He couldn’t see the edges of the room, only the women. All of them suddenly facing him, staring, pointing. They were angry—he knew that much—but he couldn’t say why.

“I don’t know Ben,” one of them said, and he recognized her from one of his many “Ashley” visits.

“I don’t know Ben,” another said. He remembered her, as well.

Then he realized he knew all of them. He’d spoken to them and they hadn’t been able to help him.

“I don’t know Ben.”

They repeated the words over and over until he thought his head would explode.

“I don’t know Ben. He has no one. No one, not even you. You let him die. It should have been you. It should have been you.”

The voices got louder and louder. He tried to answer, to tell them he already knew it should have been him, but he couldn’t speak. He lashed out, but the women only came closer and closer. Finally he took a step back and then he was falling and falling only to wake up on the hard floor, his heart racing, his body aching and his soul dark and battered from the truth.

It should have been him.

ELISSA PARKED across the street from the familiar house and looked at the rambling two story where she’d grown up.

There were changes. The once-green siding was now beige. The pine trees flanking the west side of the property had grown even taller and the small Lexus parked in the driveway was nothing like the old Taurus station wagon she remembered.

Maybe she should have called, she thought as she turned off the engine. Maybe it would have been better to give her parents a little warning. The problem was, she hadn’t been able to figure out what to say. Just showing up would be shocking, but it would force a conversation.

She’d called Bobby earlier that morning and he’d told her both her parents planned to be home most of the day. So that was something. She wouldn’t be left standing alone on the front porch.

Knowing she was only wasting time, she pocketed her keys and walked to the front door where she rang the bell. She heard a faint “I’ll get it,” then the door opened and, for the first time in eight years, her mother stood in front of her.

Leslie Towers was just shy of fifty, with highlights in her brown hair and hazel eyes that Bobby had inherited. Elissa noticed a few more lines, but otherwise her mother looked exactly as she remembered her. Only more surprised.

“Hi, Mom,” Elissa said, wishing she hadn’t left her purse locked in her car. Holding it now would give her something to do with her hands. As it was she shoved them in her jeans’ pockets and tried to figure out what she should do next.

Tears filled her mother’s eyes and her mouth trembled. “Elissa?” she asked, her voice wavering. “Elissa, is that really you?”

Elissa nodded.

“Leslie, who is it?” her father asked as he walked through the living room. “I’m not buying any more magazines. We already get too many as it—”

He stopped next to his wife and stared. “Elissa?”

She nodded. “It’s me. A little older—and hopefully wiser.”

Her father, a tall man who wore glasses, reached toward her. “Elissa?” he repeated.

“Oh, Kevin,” her mother breathed. “She’s back.”

Suddenly Elissa found herself pulled into the house and into their embrace. She was hugged and squeezed until she couldn’t breathe, but breath didn’t seem important just then. She closed her eyes and felt as if she’d finally, finally come home.

There were tears all around. Elissa hadn’t expected to cry, but there she was. Bobby appeared and joined the group hug, then they separated and there was a moment of awkwardness.

“I don’t know what to say,” her mother admitted, staring at her. “I can’t believe you’re here.”

“In the flesh,” Elissa said with a small shrug.

Her parents exchanged a glance as if not sure what to do next. They seemed happy, yet wary, which made Elissa wonder again if she should have phoned ahead and warned them she was coming.

“Let’s go in the kitchen,” her father said.

Her mother nodded, then led the way.

“Sit, sit,” her mother told everyone as she pushed Elissa into a chair at a glass-topped table. “I’m sorry. I’m in shock, I think. I can’t seem to figure out what to do next. Are you all right? Are you hungry?”

“I’m fine,” Elissa said, glancing around. Gone were the tile countertops and the harvest-gold appliances. Now the kitchen counters were dark granite and the ovens and cooktop a gleaming stainless steel. “You remodeled the kitchen.”

“About four years ago. I couldn’t stand scrubbing that awful grout or dealing with the stove anymore.” As she spoke, she pulled out a pitcher of iced tea and several glasses.

Elissa’s father took the seat across from hers and reached for her hands. “How are you really?” he asked.

The contact felt both familiar and strange. She squeezed his fingers. “I’m good, Dad. How are you?”

“Fine. Fine. Still at the bank, of course.”

“Your father’s been made district manager,” her mother said proudly.

“Wow, that’s great, Dad.”

Her mother carried the iced tea glasses to the table. “Come join us,” she told Bobby who hovered in the background.

He reluctantly took the fourth chair.

Elissa accepted a drink, then sipped while everyone stared at her.

There was a surreal combination of old memories and a new situation. She wasn’t sitting in her usual chair. The view was wrong, even discounting the remodel. But she couldn’t remember where she usually sat.

“You’ve grown up,” her father said.

“You’re so pretty,” her mother told her. “You’re all right? Healthy and everything? Do you have a job?”

“I’m good. I’m a waitress and I make jewelry on the side.”

Saying it all aloud made her want to cringe. She’d been raised to believe she would go to college and have a career, not work in a diner and barely get by. Still, she’d survived on her own under difficult circumstances and she refused to apologize for that.

“So you don’t need money?” her father asked.

Elissa stiffened. “No, Dad. I didn’t come here for money or anything. I wanted to get in touch with you.”

“Kevin, don’t,” her mother said. “Elissa’s back. That’s a good thing.”

“I know that,” her father said. “I’m happy. It’s just…” He frowned. “You were gone for so long. We didn’t know what happened to you. Your mother…”

“I missed you,” Leslie said, interrupting him and smiling. “Where do you live now? In Washington?”

Elissa remembered what Bobby had said about her mother having to go away for a rest. Had she had some kind of emotional collapse? Guilt settled in her stomach. If something had happened, Elissa’s disappearance was the reason.

“I live here. In Seattle.”

“Seattle?” Her mother’s mouth trembled. “So close. For how long?”

“A few years now.”

“But you n-never…” Leslie pressed her fingers to her mouth. “I see.”

Elissa’s father released her hand. “You didn’t want to call and let us know you were all right? You didn’t think that was important?”

Bobby swallowed and stood. “That’s my fault.” He cleared his throat. “Mom, Dad, I have to tell you something. I’m really sorry. I know you’re going to be angry and upset and I can’t blame you. What I did was wrong.”

Both their parents stared at him. “This isn’t a good time, Bobby,” Leslie said, her voice shaking. “Not a good time at all.”

Kevin put his hand on her shoulder. “Just relax, Leslie. We’re fine. Everyone is fine.”

Bobby shifted his weight and looked as if he would rather be run over and left for roadkill than speak. “I, ah, I’m the reason Elissa never got in touch with you before.”

As Elissa still didn’t know how she felt about what Bobby had done, she didn’t feel the need to come to his rescue now. She kept quiet while he explained her phoning and what he’d told her.